BLOG

Seeking the Ideal Raisers Edge Competitor for Your Nonprofit

In the realm of nonprofit management, few names are as iconic as Raiser’s Edge. As a leading CRM system, it has catered to countless organizations, providing tools to manage donor relationships, track fundraising efforts, and analyze data. However, as the nonprofit landscape evolves, many institutions find themselves in search of a Raiser’s Edge competitor that aligns more closely with their ever-evolving needs. But how does one sift through the myriad options to find the gold?

This deep dive intends to illuminate a path to the nonprofit CRM that best meets your needs. Knowing those needs may be your best starting point. Social Impact Solutions offers a free, two-minute Fundraising Quiz that provides instant results. Taking it will help you determine your organization’s strengths, weaknesses, and needs regarding donors, staff, volunteers, and software capabilities. With that valuable assessment, nonprofit leaders can ascertain the best Raiser’s Edge alternative.

Understanding Raiser’s Edge

Raiser’s Edge emerged as an all-in-one solution for nonprofits, offering modules to facilitate donor management, event planning, and other vital organizational tasks. Its robustness has made it a preferred choice for many large-scale nonprofits. Yet, with great power comes complexity. Some users find its vastness daunting, especially small to mid-sized organizations with leaner teams and more limited resources.

According to Lauren, a Raiser’s Edge reviewer on softwareadvice.com:

“We moved on and decided to cut ties with Raiser’s Edge and Blackbaud due to the difficulty we had with the software. Just not a user-friendly experience for new team members to learn.

PROS

The detailed reporting with Raiser’s Edge NXT was very detailed but trying to run reports was very difficult.

CONS

Everything. This software was so complicated, not user friendly and we were calling customer support on a daily basis because we were unable to figure things out and the “manual” is over 100 pages long…who has time to read that???”

Reasons Why Nonprofits Might Want a Change

Complex User Experience: A tool is only as good as its usability. For smaller teams, navigating a complex system can be counterproductive.
Cost Implications: Given the depth of its offerings, Raiser’s Edge can be an expensive solution, especially when additional modules are needed.

In a review posted on softwareadvice.com, Raiser’s Edge user said, “The price point is high for what you are getting, and customer support for this product is extremely poor at best.”

Demand for Modern Features: The digital era has ushered in a slew of innovative nonprofit CRM capabilities. Organizations might seek Raiser’s Edge competitors that encompass the latest in tech advancements.

Glen P., a reviewer on G2.com, switched to Virtuous and is happy with the features it offers.

“Virtuous has applied as much thought to the admin UI/UX as they have to the rich data their platform makes available. Even though the platform is a complete paradigm shift from our previous CRM, user onboarding has been reasonably smooth. This has allowed our business process teams to focus on new possibilities rather than new protocols to support old processes.

Data cleanliness is an ongoing challenge given our 25 years of data, but the Virtuous tools make it easier to find data issues and resolve them. This includes everything from deduplication to cross-platform integrations and general data and engagement accuracy.”

Essential CRM Features for Nonprofits

Before we dive into alternatives, let’s first outline the criteria nonprofits should seek in a modern CRM. According to selecthub.com, a software selection platform and research firm:

“Requirements gathering is a fundamental part of any business decision. It helps generate a list of system, functional and technical requirements from the different stakeholders involved in the process. Being confident about what requirements to look for ensures your expectations with the deliverables are clear, and that eventually enables you to make the right choice when it comes to selecting a CRM solution for your business.

No one knows your business better than you. So it’s essential to figure out your expectations from the platform before you start looking for one. Once you know what you want the software to do for your organization, it becomes easier to evaluate solutions that align with your needs.

Before you begin, it’s important to lay the proper foundation. Knowing which requirements are most important for your company will make your search more effective and less time-consuming. Armed with the knowledge of the most common features and what they can do, you’ll be able to quickly create a list of software worth pursuing.”

Let’s begin with intuitive user interface. It’s imperative for teams to quickly adapt to and navigate the CRM without steep learning curves. This saves time, money, and prevents unnecessary frustration and the risk of errors or system delays. A Princeton University article sums it up this way:

“An intuitive interface is one that works the way the user expects it to.

In other words, we find something intuitive when we don’t have to think about it.

Thinking, as anyone studying for an exam can tell you, is hard. It takes energy and attention. And thinking about two things at once is particularly difficult. That’s why distracted driving is so dangerous.

When someone is using software, they are usually thinking hard about the problem they’re solving. If they also must think about how to work the interface, they’ll have a tough time. Imagine trying to write an important letter while struggling to use the word processing software. It’s exhausting and is likely to result in a poorly-written letter.”

Scalability is also a critical feature because it provides the ability to handle workload variation while adding or removing users. The right donor management software should remain stable and maintain its performance through workload fluctuations, even those that are unexpected. As nonprofits grow and evolve, their CRM should be able to adapt without requiring an overhaul.

The ideal nonprofit CRM should have effortless integration capabilities, so it seamlessly merges with other digital tools, from marketing platforms to accounting software. Without this feature, staff must figure out individual integrations, which takes precious time from the organization’s primary mission.

Data-driven insights are the compass by which modern nonprofits navigate, making advanced analytics a key ingredient. The right CRM offers tools to assess and refine strategies, including predictive modeling, algorithms, and other statistical methods from a variety of data sources. These are imperative for donor management planning, organizing, tracking, decision making, and donor satisfaction and retention.

Donor personalization is key to donor retention and engagement, and a must-have when it comes to choosing the right software. Nonprofit CRMs that offer this nuance can be gamechangers.

According to Forbes.com, “As a nonprofit agency, you likely rely heavily on the generosity of like-minded donors. When you personalize your supporters’ experience with your organization, it can have a huge impact on your reach and donation amounts. A personal touch helps them feel more involved with your mission, making them more likely to continue donating.”

Today’s dynamic world demands accessibility from any device, anytime, making cloud accessibility another important requirement for optimal donor management software. Access to the cloud ensures the organization can function dynamically and responsively.

Raisers Edge Competitors: An Overview

As the market demand has evolved, several robust competitors have risen to the challenge. Here’s an overview of some notable ones:

Bloomerang

Features: Donor segmentation, campaign tracking, and volunteer management.

Pros: Offers a straightforward interface, suitable for smaller organizations.

Cons: Limited in terms of advanced analytics and integration capabilities.

DonorPerfect

Features: Comprehensive donor profiles, integrated online donation forms, and event registration tools.

Pros: Streamlined user experience with a rich feature set.

Cons: Some users cite challenges with customer support responsiveness.

Virtuous CRM

Features: Relationship-focused donor management, responsive fundraising techniques, and integrated email marketing.

From the Virtuous website:

“According to the Global Trends in Giving report, 85% of volunteers also give financially to those same organizations where they volunteer their time. If you don’t have a responsive volunteer-to-donor journey set up, you may be missing out on that generosity.”

Pros: Emphasizes donor relationships, offering a modern approach to fundraising. Its cloud-based system ensures teams have access from anywhere, coupled with robust analytics that drive informed strategies. And importantly, it scales to an organization’s growth.

Cons: Newer to the market, so might have a shorter track record compared to legacy systems.

If you want to learn more about Virtuous, explore its features here.

Transitioning Tips: Ensuring a Seamless CRM Migration

Switching nonprofit CRMs is no small task. It’s crucial to ensure data integrity and minimal disruption to ongoing activities:

Cleanse the Data: Prior to migration, audit and cleanse your data. This is the time to correct any discrepancies and remove redundancies.
Engage the New CRM’s Support Team: Platforms like Virtuous offer a dedicated support team to guide organizations through the transition.
Map Out Processes: Understand how tasks in Raiser’s Edge translate to the new system. This step ensures that no vital processes are overlooked during the transition.
Provide Training: Ensure that all users receive adequate training on the new CRM. The more familiar they are, the smoother the transition.
Run Parallel Systems: If feasible, run both CRMs side by side for a short period to ensure no data loss and that all processes are functioning as expected.

Conclusion

In a world where technology is advancing at breakneck speed, nonprofits must ensure their tools not only serve their current needs but also anticipate future challenges and opportunities. Begin with knowing which needs are not being met and what changes are necessary to move forward by taking the Fundraising Quiz. In minutes, you’ll have an assessment of your organizational clarity, marketing, technology, fundraising, and impact. Armed with this information, you can more accurately determine which donor CRM can take your nonprofit to the next level.

While Raiser’s Edge has been a reliable workhorse for many, the emergence of alternatives, especially platforms like Virtuous CRM, offer a fresh, modern approach tailored to the dynamic world of nonprofit management.

For leaders in the nonprofit realm, the choice is not just about a tool but a long-term partner in their mission. In that light, taking the time to evaluate, understand, and choose a CRM that aligns with both the organization’s present and future is an investment in its very heart and soul. Choose wisely, for the right CRM can elevate not just your fundraising, but your entire cause.

If you want to learn more about Social Impact Solutions and other Blackbaud competitors, read The Top Blackbaud Alternatives: The Best Nonprofit CRM and Donor Management Systems for 2024.